+- Wanderlodge Gurus - The Member Funded Wanderlodge Forum (http://www.wanderlodgegurus.com)
+-- Forum: Yahoo Groups Archive (/forumdisplay.php?fid=61)
+--- Forum: WanderlodgeForum (/forumdisplay.php?fid=63)
+--- Thread: Generator Replacement (/showthread.php?tid=2557)
Generator Replacement - Scott - 05-09-2006 03:08
To all that are considering replacing their gensets with quiet
diesels...
A word of caution when thinking this through. Believe me I have been
there and done it..
Some considerations to account for.
The genset compartment on our 86FC35 would NOT accomodate the
enclosure case that the quiet gensets come in.
The generator end of some gensets are a larger diameter than the
Kohler. The end of the genset fits UNDER the frame rail when the
genset is slid back under the coach. If the new genset is larger then
BE SURE it will go under the frame rail. I have a 17kw generator end
like the new 450's
Fuel delivery, most gensets have a fuel pump on the motor
driving the generator. Since the Kohler is tied into the RETURN LINE,
from the CAT then generally the small fuel pump on the genset will
not "pull enough fuel" to operate more than a short time before
starving for fuel and shutting down. This situation will/can be
tricky because the fault codes show low oil shutdown. No fuel, engine
starves, no oil pressure. We all know it is easier to "push" fuel
rather than "pull" fuel.
I would be happy to discuss the problems and solutions I came up with
during the replacement process which by the way took from 7:45am
Monday till 5:30 Friday. This was at the PowerTech factory, I am
convinced most others locations would have thrown the towell in long
before finally getting it to work. I can not say enough good things
about the folks at PowerTech.
ScottB
86FC35
SC
Generator Replacement - Andy Coleman - 05-10-2006 07:16
Scott,
Don't the powertech and onan quiet diesel generators both pull fuel?
Did you have to install a second line from your fuel tank to allow the
generator to "pull" fuel, instead of drawing from the existing return
line?
I would (and I'm sure others as well) appreciate to hear more about
the problems and issues you faced when replacing your genset. Might
help us decide if we should replace or modify our existing Perkins.
I can't stand the current noise from the Perkins in my 83 FC-35!
Besides the reasons you stated below, what other reasons do you prefer
the powertech over the onan? Is one quieter or more fuel efficient
than the other? How about price? A new 12.k Quiet Diesel is
retailing for almost 8K! Ouch!
Andy
83 FC-35
Spring Lake Heights, NJ
--- In WanderlodgeForum@yahoogroups.com, "Scott"
>
> To all that are considering replacing their gensets with quiet
> diesels...
>
> A word of caution when thinking this through. Believe me I have been
> there and done it..
>
> Some considerations to account for.
>
> The genset compartment on our 86FC35 would NOT accomodate the
> enclosure case that the quiet gensets come in.
>
> The generator end of some gensets are a larger diameter than the
> Kohler. The end of the genset fits UNDER the frame rail when the
> genset is slid back under the coach. If the new genset is larger then
> BE SURE it will go under the frame rail. I have a 17kw generator end
> like the new 450's
>
> Fuel delivery, most gensets have a fuel pump on the motor
> driving the generator. Since the Kohler is tied into the RETURN LINE,
> from the CAT then generally the small fuel pump on the genset will
> not "pull enough fuel" to operate more than a short time before
> starving for fuel and shutting down. This situation will/can be
> tricky because the fault codes show low oil shutdown. No fuel, engine
> starves, no oil pressure. We all know it is easier to "push" fuel
> rather than "pull" fuel.
>
> I would be happy to discuss the problems and solutions I came up with
> during the replacement process which by the way took from 7:45am
> Monday till 5:30 Friday. This was at the PowerTech factory, I am
> convinced most others locations would have thrown the towell in long
> before finally getting it to work. I can not say enough good things
> about the folks at PowerTech.
>
> ScottB
> 86FC35
> SC
>
Generator Replacement - dspithaler@... - 06-25-2006 22:42
Bill Maybe everyone is on vacation & we are the only ones home reading
the mail.
Don
89 SP 36'
Butler, PA
Oene,
I was wandering the same.
Do you think all BB's are up and running,
with no problems??
I just installed new insulation, fans/motors,
hoses and rad re-core, etc. all is well,
Good Luck with the Onan, Oene
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
Generator Replacement - oenep - 06-26-2006 01:12
I am not receiving any messages from the Forum, may be something here
at work ?
I am replacing my Kohler with a Onan Quiet Diesel, so far going pretty
good.
Oene Pomper
Generator Replacement - pattypape - 06-26-2006 01:57
Oene,
I was wandering the same.
Do you think all BB's are up and running,
with no problems??
I just installed new insulation, fans/motors,
hoses and rad re-core, etc. all is well,
Good Luck with the Onan, Oene
Bill 88FC
--- In WanderlodgeForum@yahoogroups.com, "oenep"
>
> I am not receiving any messages from the Forum, may be something
here
> at work ?
> I am replacing my Kohler with a Onan Quiet Diesel, so far going
pretty
> good.
> Oene Pomper
>
Generator Replacement - dan - 06-26-2006 03:57
What size onan are you installing?
Dan
81FCRB33
Jackson, MS
----- Original Message -----
From: oenep
To: WanderlodgeForum@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Monday, June 26, 2006 8:12 AM
Subject: [WanderlodgeForum] Generator replacement
I am not receiving any messages from the Forum, may be something here
at work ?
I am replacing my Kohler with a Onan Quiet Diesel, so far going pretty
good.
Oene Pomper
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]